An Open Letter to Guy Sebastian about Jesus

Dear Guy,

I like you. Despite myself. I even kind of like your music. I can’t really admit that in public though, but you’ve essentially forced my hand here. Generally, I don’t really like the reality TV music career pathway, but you’ve proven yourself, your music has grown, and you’ve grown on me. I probably said or thought unkind things about your success in the past – and though you’ve never met me, I’m sorry about that…

I’m also sorry to hear that you’re “reconsidering your religion” as this article puts it – that’s a shame. But it’s not like people didn’t see it coming for a while – so it shows real integrity for you to acknowledge your struggles publicly. Thanks for doing that. It must be tough to disappoint the people who have invested lots in you on the basis of your “Christian” brand, but your honesty is refreshing.

Plenty of people will try to point out that not only would you be nothing without the God who gave you the musical talent that you rely on, but that you’d be nothing without the votes you won from Christians who like to vote for Team God, given the opportunity. I’m not going to go there – though I think God gave you your voice, he gives everybody life, breath, and being – and I think, all issues with the reality TV process aside, you’ve earned your musical career. So well done. You used to think this too. Remember when you told the ABC:

“I remember when I was young and um, and at Solid Rock and um, it was when I, I think I’d been to a few meetings already and slowly getting the point, slowly getting to this point where um, where kind of God sort of almost kicked me in the butt and said, you know, this is, this is what I’ve got for you and this is the future I have for you and you can take it or leave it.”

I’m sad to hear you’ve moved away from the spot you occupied during Idol, and the post Idol touring – you were so open about what your faith meant to you, and I always appreciated that. It has to be tough sticking with Jesus when fame, fortune, and opportunity comes knocking – especially in an industry where being a faithful ambassador for Christ, as Paul calls Christians, probably comes not just at a cost in terms of the things you have to say no to, but in the opportunities you might have to turn down, and the career sacrifices you might have to make – not to mention the pressure of consistently needing to turn the glory for your hard earned success back to God… The whole premise of “Idol” makes that difficult. But you were so humble, for so long, and I was really encouraged by that.

I’m sad to hear that you feel like you were lied to. It sucks when people lie to you, or manipulate you, especially when they do it while claiming to speak for God. The God card is no fun. I’m sorry if that happened, if you feel like your popular Christian personality was built on a lie.

You said:

“My views are more based on life and discovery and research than just what I’m told,”

“Because what I was told in regards to so many things was so wrong. I’ve gone from a place where I was told there was one way and only one way, to being more in a place where I don’t think anyone has the right to say what they believe is more important or more significant.”

I found that a pretty interesting take on things. For a couple of reasons… I also wonder why you’ve misrepresented people who oppose gay marriage like you have (you said: “I don’t think anyone has the right to tell someone who they can and can’t be in love with”), typically people who oppose gay marriage are saying something a little more sophisticated than that – they’re saying that being in love with someone isn’t actually the basis for deciding who can marry who… but lets get back to the lies you were told.

I’m really glad you’re interested in a journey of discovery based on research, especially when you say you still believe in God – that’s really the best kind of life – Augustine called it “faith seeking understanding” – I’d really encourage you to make sure you look at who Jesus was, and what he said, and whether the gospels are reliable – read the guys who don’t think that’s true, like Bart Ehrman, and then read the rebuttals… weigh up the evidence. Make a decision. The truth of Christianity hangs on whether Jesus was who he says he was, and did what people said he did – especially the resurrection. If you’re not going to buy that, then eat, drink, and be merry – because not only is Christianity not the way to God, there’s probably no way to God.

The person you’re really questioning when you were told there’s only one way to God is Jesus (well, you could question John’s account of what Jesus said too, but hopefully you’ve done that in your research above)… he says, in John 14:6:

“Jesus answered, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”

That’s a big claim. An arrogant claim. But it’s the claim Jesus makes about himself, not one that people thousands of years later have made up to make some extra dollars out of their church by twisting arms out of joints, or manipulating people with any sort of intolerance building fear mongering.

Jesus claims Christianity is the only way. I think you’re right that we mere mortals can’t claim that. We don’t have that sort of authority – we should probably approach any truth claims with a degree of humility and uncertainty, especially those based on a faith that other people don’t share (that’s probably got some bearing on the gay marriage debate)… if anybody has a right to say that sort of thing though – to make an exclusive claim – it’s the guy who claims to be the son of God. A couple of verses before that quote, Jesus calls God “my father,” and in the next verse he says if people have seen him, they’ve seen God – it’s that sort of position that means, if you take his claims seriously, we have to speak about him as being the exclusive way to God.

You know all this – you’ve believed in God for a long time, you’ve been part of a church for a long time, you’ve called yourself a Christian for a long time (I’m partly writing for other people here – who are wanting to figure out what Christianity means in the context of your statements). I hope you can separate the need for Christians to be tolerant of other beliefs, and the people who hold them, while politely and graciously disagreeing, from the idea that all beliefs are equally valid. Because they can’t be – some contradict each other. It’s a shame that disagreeing with somebody is so often construed as not loving the person these days, don’t you think?

It seems you’ve struggled with the relationship between individual views, and Christianity’s exclusive claims for a while. I read some things you said when you were a Christian, stuff like:

“I think at teenagers at Paradise, they get a real sort of fresh way of looking at God, there’s so many different views on what God should be or what He is and I think it’s a real personal thing, so, so people come to a youth group and they sort of find this freedom and find this um, almost like a, “Ah, man, this is not what I thought it would be like,” and they meet some great people and, and have some great worship and stuff like that and so, yeah.”

That sounds a lot like what you’ve said today.

But then I found this video. Where you said:

“I can search for the rest of my life, but I know I’ve found, in Christ, everything that matters to me. And he is the reason why I do everything I do. He has saved me from a time when I called out his name, and he came and he gave me purpose and he gave me direction. And you know because he lives, and because I know that… we celebrate today that he rose from the dead. And out of that grave he didn’t only become a man, but became a man that took all my sins, took all my worries, and I know I can face any day, no matter what comes, because he lives.”

That’s such a clear articulation of the gospel… you even sound certain there – based on your experience of God’s faithfulness to you when you called out to him. It’s sad that you’ve lost that. It’s sad for the rest of us – we haven’t just potentially lost a brother, but a guy who was prepared to publicly champion Jesus, and what being a follower of Jesus involves…

I just want you know that I prayed for you tonight. That God would give you wisdom as you seek truth, and that you’d find truth at the heart of Christianity – in Jesus – rather than in what other people have told you is necessary. I’m sure others are too. But again, thanks for your honesty – if people were more open about what they believed, and more prepared to have conversations about faith, conversation in our country would be richer for it.

In him,



RodeoClown says:

Did you send it to him?

Nathan Campbell says:

Hey RC – I thought I replied to this – but no trace of my reply – I tweeted it to him.

I was about to ask the same thing. Let us know if he replies!

Anne says:

Guy has made his statement, I hope he does not waste one second reading this bunch of dribble. God bless you.

Bruce says:

I’m wondering how the leadership of his (former?) church are feeling right about now. that isn’t to say that goats can’t hide among the sheep under good preaching, but it’d be a discouraging thing when it appears very publicly that you’ve potentially been hosting a false convert and your preaching wasn’t enough (along with the holy spirit) to convince him of the truth claims of christianity and the good news of the gospel.

Dinky says:

Well well. Guy got plenty of practice ‘performing’ with his former church, back in the days when he was a worship leader. Interesting to hear how he now views Christianity, and how he describes, above, his relationship with God as something he was getting something out of? Maybe he shouldn’t have been serving in this way, if he wasn’t personally committed to Christ at the time? Because that makes them look bad and that they were only looking at his amazing talent. If Guy was really more clear-cut in his views and in how he didn’t want to be associated with being a Christian poster boy, he wouldn’t have jumped along on the Christian bandwagon, in ways that have helped his career and his sales! Look on You Tube and he’s there leading Christian songs, writing the anthem for 2008’s World Youth Day and performing it with the CBD guy and Paulini and performing at the Franklin Graham crusades! He’s led us all along, despite the early stamp of being a God vote. A lot of his values are Christian and his lifestyle has been as such, but… He could have distanced himself from having a Christian tag by just saying he used to lead worship at church and grew up in a Christian home – that’s all! It’s a bit of a giveaway when he hasn’t been a celebrity supporter of say, Compassion Australia, like Stan Walker is, and like how Emma Louise Birdsall is. Notice how Chris Sebastian has a song on his You Tube channel about proclaiming his belonging to Jesus, ‘before it all begins’. You might think becoming a father in the past 6 months might have made him think a bit more about Jesus and how God the Father fits into his life, and the whole theme of love pouring out for His Son? But no. I wonder where Jules stands with all of this and what her own faith is like.

LH says:

Bruce, I’m sure that Paradise Community Church are more worried about the potential falling away of a brother rather than their public reputation. No matter how powerfully one may preach, ultimately it is God who brings people to Him and God who people are turning away from, not the sermons or the ministers delivering His message.

Praying that Guy will find Truth and peace within himself, and not from anybody else except God.

Bruce says:

LH: Fully agree that they would likely be concerned about his falling away (or rather that he was probably a false convert). God definitely is the only one who saves. If your preaching is such taht someone who isn’t saved can sit under it for years and not come to a realisation that you’re not saved it might speak to the clarity and focus of the pulpit ministry.

Kat says:

Nathan – I see you are practicing censorship here removing the responses that are you don’t like – not very fair or you. These people were giving a different point of view to you on Guy Sebastian and you have chosen to manipulate the responses to your open letter to so you look good and Guy Sebastian looks bad. Not very Christian of you!!!!

Nathan Campbell says:

Hi Kat,

Not at all. I’m not sure what responses you think I’ve removed – it’s possible some have gone to spam. I’ll check – yours was held for moderation because first time commenters are moderated.

Nathan Campbell says:

Just confirmed there aren’t any in my spam folder. If they’re Facebook comments then the people who make them can always go back and make their comments private – but every comment I’ve seen is still on display. Was there a specific instance you were referring to?

Leah says:

Kat, I’d suggest reading the disclaimer on Nathan’s blog, he is generally very anti-censorship unless somebody is spewing vitriol, swearing, etc. If your comment hasn’t appeared it is probably a technical issue rather than him actively censoring posts. And considering all the comments on here criticising Nathan I have a lot of trouble seeing how you think he’s manipulating anything to make him look good and Guy look bad. Besides which, if you read the article you’d see he actually likes Guy – I don’t see any desire for him to make Guy look bad.

Cosmo says:

I made a comment too that doesnt look like it made it on 2 topics…

Nathan Campbell says:

Weird. Can I ask when? I was having some security issues and my host shut me down for a few hours this morning… could it have been in there?

Nathan Campbell says:

Apologies to anybody who has tried to post a comment here only for it to not appear – I can assure you that I do not practise censorship, especially censorship of people who disagree with me (except in the most extreme cases, this is, after all, my blog, not a soap box in a pub. Children read it. People I care about read it. Certain types of language or malicious attacks on people won’t be tolerated). You can read more about my approach to blogging in my disclaimer.

I suspect the missing comments are the result of some server issues and sporadic down time that happened this morning after a security breach with my host (since rectified).

If you tried posting something and it hasn’t appeared, please repost it.

Nathan Campbell says:

Apologies too for the lost time/effort put in to any comments that were lost into the ether.

Josh B says:

I don’t understand where the negative comments come from… Especially from so called Christians… If a brother (or sister) is at risk of leaving their faith, shouldn’t the whole family urge them toward Christ? Good work Nathan… Pointing people to Jesus is never a bad thing, and tbh if guy reads it, i reckon he will be thankful that you have given him both time and sincerity, regardless of his religious position.

Wayne Lyons says:

Hi Nathan well thought out open letter to Guy. Jesus is still the answer and the hope of the world homosexual people are now told it is normal, and natural, this is untrue it is a sin and dysfunction like other sins of fornication adultry lies and so on, homosexual marrige is another step in the wrong direction for our socitey promoted by a small group of pushy people, of whom Christ also died for. We all need Jesus and we all need to follow Him, to do otherwise especialy as Christian will only cause us to end up in grief and trouble. I will also pray for guy that he would see the truth of what the Bible has to say and that He would once again champion the cause of Christ and understand there is only one way to God. For Jesus is the Way the Truth and the Life.

[…] Sebastian in the Herald Sun last week, and after you read it, you might also be interested to read this open letter to Guy Sebastian – it’s a good […]

[…] For those who aren’t up to speed, read the original story that sparked the controversy. And here and here are the two posts I refer to that disturbed […]

Md says:

Nice letter Nathan. I’m not sure why people are confusing the term “judgemental” with the term “concern”. I think you made a great point that we as people need to look at what Jesus and the gospels say rather than relying on what people say!

[…] An open letter to Guy Sebastian about Jesus. […]

Josie says:

I love your letter to Guy Nathan, unlike so many posts I have seen, you have spoken truth from a heart of love and grace, not self righteous judgement which we as Christians can so easily fall into. Truth is truth regardless of how unpleasant it can be. But let not anybody think they have a right to stand in judgment off Guy. Who of us have had to walk his path, face his temptations? Who of us have had haughty superior thoughts about our own spiritual superiority without spending a moment praying for Guy to find his foundations again? Deception is a powerful thing,and we are all vulnerable to various forms of it, including a judgmental attitude. So let us not stand in judgment, rather pray for him, as you have done Nathan, and for ourselves that we don’t fall into a different kind of deception. Thanks Nathan for responding in such a Christlike way.